Top 300ReviewsBlogAboutDisclosure

Browse by category

ThematicDraftingDiceEconomicCard GameWorker PlacementLegacy & CampaignCooperativeArea ControlDeck-BuildingTile-LayingTwo-PlayerWargameAbstractParty
Browse the 300
Heavy Euro2022
Carnegie box art

Box art via BoardGameGeek

Heavy Euro

Carnegie

A gorgeous industrial-era puzzle where one clever action ripples across the whole table.

3.8 out of 53.8/5

Designed by Xavier Georges · 2022

Players1-4
Play time90-120 min
WeightMedium-Heavy
Ages12+
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link · supports the site, costs you nothing extra
The verdict

Carnegie is a smart, beautiful mid-to-heavy euro that rewards planning ahead, as long as you can stomach a wall of iconography and a slightly solved opening. If you like your action selection to feel like a chain reaction, this one's a keeper.

Best for: Euro fans who love a tight engine and don't mind a steep first game

The full review

What it is

Carnegie puts you in the late 1800s as an industrialist building a company across departments: management, construction, R&D, and a sprawling US map you fill with workers. The engine that drives it is the Timeline. Each round one player picks a department to activate, and here's the hook, everyone activates it. So your choice isn't just yours. You're handing the whole table a turn, which makes every pick feel loud and a little dangerous.

The catch

Now the honest part. This game asks a lot of you up front. Reviewers keep flagging the same thing: the iconography is dense, and your first play is mostly translation work with the rulebook open. There's also a balance gripe that comes up again and again, R&D is just better, so the opening draft can turn into a scramble for it. At two players you're saddled with a mandatory neutral company that some folks find fiddly, and once a group solves the lines, it can lose a little spark.

Who it's for

But when it clicks, it really clicks. The income sequence, timing your workers home for a fat payout, is the kind of small satisfaction that keeps people coming back. And those boards with the sliding tabs are just lovely to fiddle with. This is a thinky euro that hides its weight behind a colorful coat of paint. If you want a planning puzzle with real table interaction and you'll forgive a rough first night, deal it out. If you bounce off symbol-heavy rules, sit this one out.

What other players say

This write-up is grounded in real reviews and player discussion, not just one opinion. A few worth reading:

More from the shelf

All reviews