Top 300ReviewsBlogAboutDisclosure

Browse by category

ThematicDraftingDiceEconomicCard GameWorker PlacementLegacy & CampaignCooperativeArea ControlDeck-BuildingTile-LayingTwo-PlayerWargameAbstractParty
Browse the 300
Asymmetric War Game2011
War of the Ring: Second Edition box art

Box art via BoardGameGeek

Asymmetric War Game

War of the Ring: Second Edition

The whole War of the Ring on your table, dice, doom, and all.

4.1 out of 54.1/5

Designed by Roberto Di Meglio, Marco Maggi, Francesco Nepitello · 2011

Players2-4
Play time150-240 min
WeightHeavy
Ages14+
Check price on AmazonAffiliate link · supports the site, costs you nothing extra
The verdict

If you want the entire trilogy compressed into one tense, asymmetric afternoon, almost nothing does it better. Just bring patience and a big table.

Best for: Two players who love Tolkien and don't mind a long, heavy fight

The full review

What it is

Here's the pitch. One of you plays the Shadow, trying to crush the Free Peoples by conquest or by corrupting Frodo. The other plays the Free Peoples, holding the line while sneaking the Fellowship toward Mount Doom. Each round you roll a fistful of action dice, and the faces decide what you can even attempt: move armies, muster troops, nudge a nation toward war, play an event. Two sides, two completely different toolkits, one map of Middle-earth.

The catch

The pull of it is the squeeze. The Free Peoples want to march and fight, but every die spent on the war is a die not spent guiding the Ring, and the Shadow's Hunt pool keeps biting Frodo with corruption. Players consistently call it one of the most thematic strategy games ever made, and they're right. The flip side: it's heavy. Setup is fiddly, similar minis are hard to tell apart, and the dice plus card luck genuinely frustrate some folks who want pure control.

Who it's for

So who's this for? Two people who love Tolkien and want the whole saga, not a tidy hour. It plays 2-4, but the heart of it is the duel, and the four-player team version waters down the tension a bit. Expect a steep first game and some analysis paralysis while you learn what all those dice can do. Push through that, and few games on the shelf feel this much like the books fighting back.

What other players say

This write-up is grounded in real reviews and player discussion, not just one opinion. A few worth reading:

War of the Ring: Second Edition is featured in these lists

More from the shelf

All reviews